Hoax – Researchers discovered a subterranean city beneath the Egyptian pyramids.
Analysis
Recently, news about the supposed discovery of a vast subterranean city beneath the Giza pyramids in Egypt has been widely circulating in various media outlets (mainly the more sensationalist ones).
Reports claim that Italian and Scottish researchers identified significant underground structures using advanced radar technologies and that this could represent a milestone in understanding life in the past. Read one of the messages:
Researchers discover “subterranean city” beneath the Egyptian pyramids. Researchers from Italy and Scotland have discovered the existence of a subterranean city beneath the Giza Pyramids in Egypt through an X-ray study. Scientists used a technology that transforms radar signals into phonetic information, allowing the detection of millimetric vibrations. Video credits: Illustration
Fact-Checking
Despite being published in many media outlets and reproduced by numerous others, this story is more about sensationalism than facts.
To clarify the authenticity of these claims, we will analyze the following questions:
1) What is the context of the story claiming a subterranean city was discovered beneath the Egyptian pyramids?
2) Was a subterranean city found beneath the Egyptian pyramids?
3) What errors are found in the research in question?
What is the context of the story claiming a subterranean city was discovered beneath the Egyptian pyramids?
The news about the discovery of a supposed subterranean city beneath the Giza pyramids originated from a study conducted by Italian and Scottish researchers.
The claim is that, using ground-penetrating radar (GPR) technologies, they allegedly identified significant underground structures, including deep cylindrical formations and interconnected corridors, suggesting the existence of a vast underground network beneath the Giza Plateau. The story gained traction but was soon debunked.
Was a subterranean city found beneath the Egyptian pyramids?
Despite the claims presented, the archaeological community has received these assertions with skepticism. Experts highlight that the techniques used in the study are not conclusive and lack validation through physical excavations.
Furthermore, the absence of peer review (as noted in this Snopes article) and the lack of concrete evidence raise doubts about the existence of such a subterranean city. The renowned Egyptian archaeologist Zahi Hawass classified the claims as “completely wrong” and “fake news.”
What errors are found in the research in question?
Critics point out several flaws in the research. First, the methodology relying solely on radar data without corroborating with excavations or physical evidence is considered insufficient to validate such discoveries.
Additionally, the interpretation of radar data can be ambiguous, leading to potentially erroneous conclusions. The lack of publication in reputable scientific journals and the absence of peer review also undermine the study’s credibility.
Moreover, some versions of the story circulate with videos and images generated by artificial intelligence, with no connection to the original research, contributing to the spread of misinformation.
Conclusion
The claims about the discovery of a subterranean city beneath the Egyptian pyramids lack concrete evidence and scientific validation. So far, there is no proof of such underground structures beneath the Giza Plateau. Therefore, the information being spread should be approached with caution, as there is no scientific support to confirm the existence of a subterranean city under the pyramids.
Unproven hoax 👎
PS: This article is a suggestion from readers of Boatos.org. If you would like to suggest a topic to Boatos.org, contact us via email at [email protected] or WhatsApp (link here: https://wa.me/556192755610).